How to Get the Best Quote from a Contractor: Tips for Smart Homeowners

Getting Accurate, Competitive Contractor Quotes

Getting quotes from contractors is a critical step in any home improvement project, but many homeowners approach the process in ways that lead to inaccurate estimates, unexpected costs, and frustration. By preparing properly and knowing what to look for, you can get quotes that truly reflect what your project will cost and avoid the most common pitfalls.

Follow these proven strategies to get better quotes, compare them effectively, and ultimately hire the right contractor at a fair price.

Before You Contact Contractors

Define Your Project Clearly

The more specific you are about what you want, the more accurate your quotes will be. Before calling contractors, define the scope of work in detail. Instead of saying you want to remodel your kitchen, specify that you want to replace the cabinets, install quartz countertops, add a tile backsplash, upgrade the lighting, and install a new sink and faucet while keeping the existing layout.

Create a written description of the project, gather inspiration photos showing the style and materials you like, and establish a realistic budget range. This preparation allows contractors to provide specific, comparable quotes rather than vague estimates based on assumptions.

Research Fair Market Pricing

Before getting quotes, spend 30 minutes researching average costs for your type of project in your area. This gives you a baseline to evaluate the quotes you receive. If a quote is dramatically below or above the market average, that is a signal to ask questions about why.

How Many Quotes Should You Get?

The standard recommendation is three to five quotes for any significant project. Fewer than three does not give you enough data points for comparison. More than five becomes time-consuming for both you and the contractors, and the additional data rarely changes your decision. Three solid quotes from qualified contractors is usually the sweet spot.

What to Look for in a Contractor Quote

A professional contractor quote should include detailed information that allows you to understand exactly what you are paying for. Here are the essential elements every quote should contain:

• Itemized costs: Material costs, labor costs, and any subcontractor costs should be broken out separately
• Material specifications: Exact products, brands, models, and quantities for all materials
• Scope of work: A detailed description of every task included in the price
• Timeline: Estimated start date, project duration, and completion date
• Payment schedule: When payments are due and how much at each stage
• Permit costs: Whether permit fees are included or separate
• Cleanup and disposal: What the contractor is responsible for removing and cleaning
• Warranty information: What is warranted and for how long
• Exclusions: What is specifically not included in the price

Comparing Quotes Apples to Apples

The most common mistake homeowners make is comparing quotes purely on total price. Two quotes might look very different in price but actually include different scopes of work, different quality materials, or different levels of service. Before comparing prices, make sure each quote covers the same scope of work and specifies comparable materials.

Create a simple comparison chart that lists the key elements of each quote side by side: materials specified, scope of work included, timeline, warranty terms, and total price. This visual comparison makes it much easier to identify where the differences lie and whether a higher-priced quote offers better value.

Negotiating with Contractors

It is perfectly acceptable to negotiate with contractors, but approach it respectfully and strategically. Rather than simply asking them to lower their price, try these approaches that create win-win outcomes:

• Flexible scheduling: Offer to let the contractor start during their slow season or work between other projects in exchange for a discount
• Material alternatives: Ask if there are comparable materials at a lower price point that would reduce the overall cost
• Bundle projects: If you have multiple projects, bundling them with one contractor often results in a lower combined price
• Pay terms: Some contractors offer a discount for paying by check instead of credit card, as they save on processing fees
• Referral agreement: Offer to refer friends and family or allow the contractor to use your project for their portfolio in exchange for a modest discount

Red Flags in Contractor Quotes

Watch out for these warning signs that a quote may lead to problems. An extremely low bid compared to others usually means the contractor is cutting corners on materials, underestimating the scope of work, or planning to add costs later through change orders. A quote with no material specifications gives the contractor room to substitute cheaper products. A demand for a large upfront payment (more than 30%) puts your money at risk.

Also be cautious of verbal-only quotes. Any legitimate contractor should be willing to put their quote in writing. A written quote protects both you and the contractor by clearly documenting what was agreed upon.

Get Free Quotes Today

Ready to get started? FindMyContractor makes it easy to request free quotes from multiple verified contractors in your area. Browse contractor profiles, read real reviews, and connect with professionals who are ready to provide detailed, competitive quotes for your project.